The summer has gone by so quickly this year, and in a few ways, it has been a bummer of a season. First there was not enough rain and all the grass died, then too much rain and everything flooded. It was too hot to be outside for very long, and we were too busy to slow down and sip on a sweet taste of summer in the backyard. And then, of course, our grill died (sigh). Despite the fact that Labor Day is behind us, we still technically have a few weeks left of summer and I’m here to enjoy the last of it.

This lemon cream pie cocktail is simple, but still feels fancy enough to turn an ordinary September weekend into a special occasion. There are no fancy syrups or bitters required, and no hard-to-find spirits. All you need is a shaker, some ice from the freezer door, a few vanilla wafers if you want a dessert-inspired rim, and four liquid ingredients:

Limoncello is the star of this show, and I’m hard pressed to find anything that tastes more summery. It is a popular Italian liqueur, traditionally made from lemons grown on the Amalfi coast. The process for making limoncello involves stripping the bright yellow peel from a basketful of fresh lemons, macerating them in sugar and mixing with neutral grain alcohol (usually vodka). It is delightful for sipping or mixing into other drinks. My particular brand of limoncello checks in at only 28% ABV, which translates to 56 proof. Nice and easy. 😎

Whipped cream vodka is a novelty spirit, and it tastes exactly as you might expect. Like a boozy, sweet whipped cream. This is not my usual path to “happy hour,” but every now and again, it’s fun to use in a frilly drink. Eventually, I will share my other recipes to help you use up your bottle. Like the limoncello, this whipped cream vodka is also on the easy end of the booze meter at 60-proof. Several brands make whipped cream vodka; if you can’t find it, check out my substitution tips in the notes section of the click-to-print recipe card below. 

The other two ingredients needed for this drink are lemonade— fresh homemade would be awesome, but I use Simply Lemonade— and a splash of half and half. 

Finally, if you want your lemon cream pie cocktail to have more of a “dessert” vibe, consider crushing few vanilla wafer cookies for the rim of your martini glass. This was a suggestion by my friend, Pam, who is wild about both lemon and fancy cocktails. As I was developing this drink, I had invited Pam over for sampling, and we pondered what might be a pretty garnish for such a light, fresh drink. As we sipped and marveled over how much it tastes like lemon cream pie, the idea of a vanilla crust came to Pam, and here we are!

Warm weather’s a-wasting— let’s get to making this drink, shall we? For each drink, you’ll need two ounces of that lovely limoncello. This may seem heavy handed, but remember that it’s low-proof. An ounce of the whipped cream vodka is next, and then a half-ounce each of the lemonade and half-and-half. Combine all of that in your shaker and give it a little swirl before adding a cup of ice. I’ve learned along the way that it’s best to add ice after all your other ingredients are in the shaker; otherwise, they will not dilute at the same rate.

Give it a solid shake for about 20 seconds, then strain into your prepared glasses and enjoy the rest of summer with a little taste of sunshine!

Lemon Cream Pie Cocktail

• Servings: 1 drink
• Prep Time: 5 minutes
• Difficulty: So Easy!
• Print

This pretty drink is easy to make from simple ingredients. Add an extra touch of dessert by rimming the glass with crushed vanilla wafers!

Ingredients

• 2 oz. limoncello liqueur
• 1 oz. whipped cream vodka (see notes for substitution)
• 1/2 oz. fresh lemonade
• 1/2 oz. half-and-half
• A handful of vanilla wafers, crushed (for glass rim, if desired)
• Thin slice of lemon (for garnish, if desired)

Notes: Whipped cream vodka is a lower proof, flavored sweet vodka, and several spirit companies make a version of it. If you can’t get your hands on it, substitute regular vodka (but only 3/4 ounce), and use a sweetened whipped cream in place of half-and-half. This won’t be exactly the same, but close enough to keep the balance of sweetness without too much harsh alcohol bite.

For non-U.S. readers, half-and-half is a dairy product containing approximately 12% milk fat, somewhere in between whole milk and heavy cream. If you cannot get your hands on it, go with light cream or whipping cream. Milk will be too thin. Be sure to shake the drink really well before straining.

Directions

1. Prepare glasses by swiping a lemon slice around the outer edge of a cocktail glass, then rolling the outside only through the crushed vanilla wafers. Fill the glass with ice and set aside to chill for about 5 minutes.
2. Add limoncello, whipped cream vodka, lemonade and half-and-half to a cocktail shaker and give the mixture a little swirl to blend. Add one cup of ice cubes and shake firmly for 20 seconds, or until the outside of the shaker is uncomfortably cold.
3. Empty ice from glasses and then strain the cocktail into the glass. Garnish with a slice of lemon.