It’s that time of year again, and I don’t mean Christmas in July. I’m completing another trip around the sun this weekend, and what better way to celebrate than with a signature cocktail for the birthday girl? 

My husband, Les, is throwing me a party, and though many of the party details are a secret (including most of the guest list), I do at least know what will be on the drink menu because the venue gave us the option to request a special cocktail—yay! I love a theme for a party, and I’ve decided that my signature birthday drink should be reminiscent of the one that was in my hand back in the days when I was first “of age” to imbibe. Oops, did I just give away my age?! 

DeKuyper had just released its Peachtree™️ schnapps, and everyone who was anyone— at least among the girls— was sipping on fuzzy navels, a blend of this syrupy sweet schnapps and equally sweet orange juice. The drink gave us a fun little buzz, and it was perfectly simple for all the bridal showers that my girlfriends were having.

Fast forward, ahem, a few decades and I’m still fond of the “idea” of the fuzzy navel, though I could never stomach the sweetness of it today. So I did what I always do— a modern makeover of an old favorite into a cocktail that is familiar but fresh— this one is easy to make, easy to drink, easy on the alcohol and yes, easy on the eyes.

What’s fun about a fuzzy navel spritz?

First of all, there’s no peach schnapps! The last time I tasted that stuff, I cringed at the artificial aftertaste. No, this glow-up gets its “fuzzy” flavor from a peach puree that concentrates real peaches into a thick syrup that plays nice with a number of alcoholic spirits— vodka, bourbon, blanco tequila, need I go on? It’s sweet (but naturally so), and a little goes a long way. You can find this product in the mixers section of a larger supermarket, or in the same aisle of a wine or spirits store.

The “navel” aspect of my upscale drink comes from Aperol. This slightly bitter, orange-meets-herbal aperitivo from Italy brings an instant citrusy balance to the sweetness of the peach puree. Aperol is having more than a fleeting moment of popularity, and I decided to ride that wave for my birthday.

Finally, the base of the drink is Cava, Spain’s counterpart to champagne, bringing a little “fizzy” to my “fuzzy,” and a splash of sparkling water on top softens the drink for superb sipability. Any sparkling will do, whether club soda, seltzer or one of the fancy European options. If you happen to find one scented with orange or peach, even better!

If at first I don’t succeed, and I didn’t

This cocktail idea has been floating in my mind since at least my last birthday, but it was only in the past few weeks that I got serious about making it work. My first effort looked nothing like what you see here. It included vodka, peach nectar (which is not as peach-forward as it sounds), orange juice, Aperol and prosecco. It was too boozy, too sweet, not very peachy, not pretty and not refreshing at all. In other words, it needed a lot of work!

The peach flavor needed to be concentrated. I considered cooking peaches down into a puree to replace that so-called nectar, but would my birthday venue be willing to do that when I handed them the recipe? Relying on a pre-made mixer felt like cheating, but I am so glad that I checked out this peach puree. It’s just sugar, peaches, citric acid and a preservative—not so bad after all! Did I mention that it is great with bourbon, too? I’ll save that for another post. 😉

The vodka got 86’d because I wanted this to be a lower proof drink for easy summer sipping. Prosecco wasn’t right because the peach puree makes this drink sweet enough. Cava feels like the perfect choice, but a California brut would be great as well.

In the name of research and development, I’ve made quite a few iterations of this drink, fiddling with the ratios to balance the flavor. A traditional Aperol spritz follows a 3-2-1 ratio of bubbly, Aperol and sparkling water. But two ounces of Aperol was overwhelming to the peach, so I’ve cut it almost in half. The ratios you see in the click-to-print recipe below are my final decision, and I think it’s perfect.

Just one more thing…

Though a spritz is typically mixed directly in the glass, this one does require a shaker to mix the Aperol and the peach puree, which is very thick. The bubbly ingredients should not go into the shaker, unless you want to clean the whole kitchen when it bubbles over! My method is to measure the chilled Cava into the glass first, shake up the Aperol and peach puree with a decent amount of ice, and then do what pro bartenders call a “dirty pour,” ice and all, into the glass with the Cava. A final splash of sparkling water at the end, and a wedge of fresh, juicy peach finishes this drink. 

Fuzzy Navel Spritz

• Servings: 1 cocktail
• Prep Time: 2 minutes
• Difficulty: Easy!
• Print

This is my modernized interpretation of a drink I loved back in the 1980s. It's less sweet than the fuzzy navels of my youth, but still light and very refreshing!

Ingredients

• 3 oz. Cava or other dry, sparkling wine
• 3/4 oz. peach puree syrup (Reàl brand)
• 1 1/4 oz. Aperol
• 1 or 2 oz. sparkling water, seltzer or club soda
• Slice of fresh peach or orange, to garnish

Note: Most spritz cocktails are built directly in the glass, but this one requires a shaker for mixing the thick peach puree. Use a balloon glass, such as a red wine glass, that will hold all of the ice you use for mixing the drink.

Directions

1. Pour Cava into the serving glass.
2. Add peach puree and Aperol to a cocktail shaker. Add about one cup ice cubes and shake for several seconds until the shaker is frosty and very cold.
3. Pour the entire contents of the shaker (ice and all) into the glass with the Cava. Top with sparkling water. Garnish with a fresh fruit slice.